In May 1975 the United States left Laos with no plan for the Hmong who had fought beside its agents for fourteen years. A handful of refugee workers in Thailand set out to change that, one case file at a time. This feature follows their story, drawing on Larry Clinton Thompson’s 2010 book and its tables.
May 1975: the last days of Long Tieng
Long Tieng, Lima Site 20 Alternate, was General Vang Pao’s headquarters and one of the largest towns in Laos. It sat in a valley at about 3,100 feet, with a 4,200-foot runway and a limestone ridge at one end. At the corner of the runway stood the CIA compound, which Jerry Daniels had named “Sky” after his home state of Montana.
By the spring of 1975 the Hmong army was outnumbered and American air support had been ended by the 1973 agreements. On May 5, Prime Minister Souvanna Phouma called Vang Pao in and told him to cooperate with the communists. Vang Pao pulled the general’s stars from his collar, threw them on the floor and left the room. Daniels, who had been his case officer since 1965, told him the war could not go on, because the guns and ammunition he needed would not come.
Daniels asked the Embassy in Vientiane to fly out 2,500 people, then 3,500, mostly officers above the rank of captain and their families. The Embassy was busy preparing for a possible evacuation of Americans. In Bangkok, General Heinie Aderholt took a call from someone who warned that thousands of Hmong were stranded, and he began lining up aircraft. He reached Bird Air pilot Matt Hoff at Don Muang Airport and offered a premium for one more flight in a C-130. Continental Air Services pilots Les Strouse and Allen Rich brought two C-46s, and the flights started on May 12.
The aircraft were old and the valley was tight, so the pilots took out the seats and strung ropes across the cargo floor for passengers to hold. Rich’s flight log that day recorded a crowd of about 14,000 and shooting on the ramp. One of the first flights carried Captain Kue Chaw, a radio operator for Sky, with his team and their families.
On May 13 the North Vietnamese and Pathet Lao broke through the last outpost on the road to Long Tieng. Daniels planned to get Vang Pao out the next day without being seen, because thousands of Hmong were watching the general. Bird Air pilot Jack Knotts flew a small helicopter to a ridge above a lake. Dave Kouba kept a Porter aircraft on the runway as a decoy while Daniels lingered nearby, then drove off in his Bronco. The two men boarded the helicopter and left. A Pathet Lao battalion walked into Long Tieng the next day.
Washington had not been looking in this direction. A State Department briefing book compiled that month for congressional testimony said nothing about Laos or Laotian refugees. Its statement on refugee arrangements was dated May 12, the day the Long Tieng flights began.
Across the Mekong
Tens of thousands of Hmong remained in and around Long Tieng, and many set out for Thailand. A column more than a mile long walked toward Vientiane and came under fire at the Nam Lik bridge, where soldiers turned back the crowd. The survivors scattered. Some hired boats downstream. Others walked in small groups at night, with their weapons buried, over mountain trails as high as 9,000 feet. Hunger drove them as much as fear did, since the American rice that had fed the highlands had stopped arriving.
At the river, families built rafts from banana stalks and vines and held on while the men paddled. Few Hmong knew how to swim. Soldiers patrolled both banks. Many people were lost in the crossing, and the families who arrived carried those losses with them. Our poem The Hush Before the Dawn remembers the children of that journey. By the end of 1975, about 40,000 Hmong and other Lao had crossed, and more followed in later years.
Thai police took new arrivals to a walled detention center called So Ko Tou. After weeks or months, lowland Lao went on to Nong Khai and Hmong families went to Ban Vinai. Early groups also lived at Nam Pong, near Udorn. Vang Pao left Thailand on June 18, 1975. Daniels took him to Missoula, where Vang Pao bought a 402-acre ranch, and then went back to Thailand. He chose to stay with the Hmong and help however he could.
A second view from the river: Yang See
While the Udorn team worked the paperwork, a Hmong officer known as Glassman was already on the Mekong. Yang See, who had worked under Daniels on a development program in Military Region 2, resigned on May 10, crossed to Nong Khai and, with the governor’s approval, opened a shelter at Wat Samakkhi on May 13. The first Hmong groups crossed on May 14, the camp grew to about 2,500 people within days, and buses began carrying people to Nam Phong on May 21. On May 27 Daniels told him that new crossings had to stop (See, n.d., pp. 14, 17, 23, 26). The feature Glassman: Yang See and the Hidden Crossing at Nong Khai follows the days on a map.
Three officers in Udorn
Mac Thompson, a 34-year-old USAID officer, had driven out of Vientiane in a Volkswagen bus on June 26, 1975. On August 4 the Embassy sent him to the consulate in Udorn to open a refugee processing office. Daniels joined him there, and so did John Tucker, who had been under house arrest in Laos for five days in May and later wrote from Guam to propose a program for Lao refugees. The three divided up the work. Thompson took informal charge, Daniels took the Hmong and other highlanders, and Tucker took the Thai Dam and lowland Lao.
The policy mood in Washington was cautious. On August 1 the attorney general had paroled 3,466 Lao in a special program, and the Hmong were not on the list. Assistant Secretary of State Philip Habib told Congress that the highland peoples were particularly suited to the area of Thailand and were not easily resettled. A Hmong delegation met Ambassador Whitehouse on August 4 and found him noncommittal, and an immigration officer told them they would be denied entry because mountain life had not prepared them for American high-tech society. A cable on September 30 said the department was concerned about the large and growing number of Hmong in the Lao program.
Daniels and Thompson saw it differently. For Daniels the issue was a promise. As he told the Hmong, Americans had said that if they fought for the United States and lost, they would be taken care of. The first opening came when INS officer Sam Feldman visited Nam Pong in August. Daniels and Thompson introduced him to Dr. Yang Dao, then the only Hmong with a Ph.D., and to Hmong officers wearing American field jackets covered with patches and medals. Feldman called Washington afterward, and the picture began to change.
The Hmong had their own mixed feelings. Many hoped to remain close to Laos and return one day, and Vang Pao encouraged that hope. If it proved impossible, they asked for something like a reservation in the United States where they could stay together.
A visitor in a borrowed station wagon
Lionel Rosenblatt was a 31-year-old Foreign Service officer in January 1975 when the fall of Phuoc Binh made him organize a lunch group to plan for evacuating Vietnamese. In April he flew to Saigon with Craig Johnstone and helped about 200 Vietnamese leave. In Washington he then headed the Office of Special Concerns in the interagency task force.
In late October 1975 he went to Thailand. The Embassy gave him a four-wheel-drive station wagon and a Thai driver, and he spoke Thai. He toured some of the sixteen camps in monsoon mud and saw crowding, dysentery, malaria and a daily ration of about 500 grams of rice per person. In Udorn he met Thompson, Daniels and Tucker. Thompson remembered a long-haired visitor announcing his name, and the group talked into the night. Rosenblatt overslept and missed his plane, so Thompson and Daniels suggested he spend the extra hours in a Hmong camp.
There he met men who used American radio names such as Lucky, Judy and Bison, former soldiers, radio operators and pilots of a war most Americans had never heard of. He left feeling that the Hmong should be at the front of the resettlement line. He drafted a telegram to Washington proposing that eligible Cambodian and Lao refugees, including Hmong, be taken in. The Embassy was slow to send it. Rosenblatt phoned Ken Quinn at the National Security Council, who called Ambassador Whitehouse and said the White House was waiting for the telegram. It went out within hours.
Back in Washington, Rosenblatt asked Shep Lowman in the refugee office for support. Lowman said that someone would have to go to Thailand, set up a program and make the case to Congress. Rosenblatt agreed, on the condition that Lowman fight the bureaucratic battles at home. Colleagues came to call Lowman “Mr. Inside” and Rosenblatt “Mr. Outside.” In January 1976 the State Department proposed an Expanded Parole Program for 11,000 more Indochinese.
Soi One, 1976
Rosenblatt reached Bangkok in early January with four colleagues. They moved into an old AID house on Soi One, off Sukhumvit Road. Before they began, he asked Daniels to commit to full-time refugee work and to stay away from clandestine activity. He hired thirteen Peace Corps volunteers who were finishing their tours, at $1,000 a month, which was more than ten times what they had been earning. A blackboard in the house carried a running tally of cases, because INS would count the 11,000 places exactly.
The work was full of details no manual had covered. Many camp couples had never registered a marriage, so an Anglican priest married them in the Embassy cafeteria, which counted as American territory. Many Hmong men had two or three wives, and American law allowed one. Daniels set up a procedure in which the husband named one wife for the application and the others lived separately in the camp, and it often took a year or more before the family could move. Albert Corcos of ICEM handled medical exams, flights and Thai paperwork. Someone counted 91 seals, stamps, signatures and initials needed to let a refugee leave Thailand. Corcos also lent Rosenblatt the money to pay the volunteers when U.S. funds were slow.
Choosing who would go was painful. Rosenblatt told his team that the number of places was fixed, so they had to decide who was most qualified. Mac Thompson devised a point system that rewarded relatives in the United States, years of military or civil service, and education abroad. The best-qualified families moved to the front. Thompson also added a joke to his instructions: anyone who said they liked wine and cheese could be referred to France, and anyone who liked snow could be referred to Canada.
The program faced resistance in Washington. Congressman Joshua Eilberg, who chaired the House immigration subcommittee, favored a smaller number of 3,000 and called for more consultations. The funds were due to expire on June 30, 1976, and the debate ran down to the last day. The money was obligated that evening. A cable to Bangkok congratulated the team on a “cliff-hanger of historic proportions.” The refugee workers in Bangkok and Udorn also faced criticism from UNHCR, whose Bangkok representative feared that resettlement would draw more refugees to Thailand.
Waiting in Ban Vinai
By the early 1980s Ban Vinai was the largest Hmong settlement that had ever existed. It sat among wooded hills in northern Thailand. The camp was divided into seven centers, each with its own leader, and a head man who in 1980 was Vang Neng, a cousin of Vang Pao. When Vang Neng was approved for resettlement, some of his followers and the JVA asked that he stay, and he did for a time. Families lived in huts of scrap wood and bamboo or in stilt longhouses, grew upland rice, squash and beans, raised chickens and turkeys, kept flowers in pots and played soccer. Shamans, herbalists, letter writers and noodle sellers kept businesses going, and wats and churches appeared. JVA workers lived inside the camp in wooden barracks and ate Hmong food.
The Hmong brought their own medicine. Many were wary of vaccinations at first and relied on shamans, herbalists and spiritual guides. Language was a major worry, and the camp ran literacy classes in Hmong and English. When buses arrived every three or four days to carry approved families to Bangkok, the mood was often sad. People had seen only photographs and heard cassette tapes from relatives in America, and the stories sounded lonely. Rosenblatt worried that a leader in the camp would arrive in the U.S. as just another refugee without a skill. The Hmong also wanted to keep their identity as Hmong.
The first offer of sponsorship for a Hmong family, as Mac Thompson recalled it, came in November or December 1976 from Minneapolis. The man chosen had a few questions. He asked how many Hmong lived there and was told none. “Somebody has to be first,” Thompson said. He went. Thompson’s book also records Kue Chaw leaving in May 1976 and settling in Philadelphia, so the dates in the book vary with the telling. What is clear is that families began to arrive in small numbers in 1976 and in large numbers from 1979 to 1980.
The same team on the Cambodian border
The refugee workers in Bangkok also took on Cambodian cases. On June 12, 1979, Rosenblatt and Yvette Pierpaoli drove to Wat Ko, a temple near Aranyaprathet, where about 6,000 Cambodians were being held before a forced return. France, the United States and Australia had won agreement to choose 1,200 for resettlement. A team of four had three hours to pick people and load buses, and they left with 1,296. Later that month the Thai pushed back tens of thousands of Cambodians at Preah Vihear. A UNHCR report of July 3 estimated 42,000 had been pushed back, with about 3,000 deaths. Pierpaoli and Rosenblatt then lobbied for survivors, and a Thai official listed 922 who were taken to Bangkok.
From a team to a system
Rosenblatt returned to Washington in August 1976 and later went back to Bangkok in spring 1978 to lead the expanded program. By then Lowman had seen that the volume of work called for a different structure. He created the Joint Voluntary Agency model, in which a single voluntary agency handled paperwork in each country, and picked the International Rescue Committee to lead it in Thailand. By mid-1978 it had about twenty American staff, many of them former Peace Corps volunteers who had worked for Rosenblatt in 1976. After the decision of June 14, 1978 to take 25,000 refugees in the coming year, the pipeline grew. By the end of the 1970s, Thompson writes, refugee programs made up about 20 percent of the State Department’s budget.
April 1982: Jerry Daniels
On April 30, 1982, John Tucker called Jim Schill in Washington to say that Daniels had been found dead in his Bangkok apartment. The body had been there several days, and the death was attributed to a gas leak from a water heater. Tucker and Schill accompanied his remains to Missoula, where Vang Pao and about fifteen Hmong and CIA mourners met them. The casket had been sealed by order of the Embassy in Bangkok, and some of the Hmong wondered aloud about the circumstances. We note that part of the community’s memory without drawing a conclusion.
The Hmong held a traditional funeral and wrote a eulogy that thanked him for more than twenty years of service, for living in their villages, and for seeing that Hmong families were given the opportunity to begin new lives in America. His headstone in Missoula carries a Hmong scene from the highlands.